Cat Opinion Game! {Spoilers!duh}

[Deleted]

Hi all, Cheepa here and welcome to the Cat Opinion Game!
How this works: Someone will name a cat from the books, and you state your opinion about him/her.
Here is an example-

Cat1: Bluestar

Cat2: She was a good leader, and suffered a lot. Mothwing

Cat1or3: She was ignorant because of her non-belief in Starclan. Hawkfrost

And so forth.
Got it? I'll start:

Firestar

[Moonfur]

Good game idea! But maybe you should but a spoiler alert in the title, since we're talking about the books

He was a great leader, even if he started as a kittypet. He died saving his clan.
Silverstream

[Deleted]

Silverstream was one of my favorite cats, her death was the saddest thing I've seen in warriors thus far. Her line when she stood up to her father about Graystripe was amazing, and I would pick her over Millie any day.

Millie

[Talia]

(Sorry, i haven't read the warrior books in a while so i might be bit rusty)

I think she should have stayed a kitty pet. She was a sucky mother as she mentally abused one kit that caused it to train with the dark forest and loved the other a bit to much because of it's disability.

Crookedstar

[Deleted]

Crookedstar went though some of the hardest stuff in life, and had the most jerkish mother ever. He was a good cat.

Rainflower {Crooked's jerk mother}

[Speckledpaw]

Rainflower was the worst mother ever.I can't belive that Shellheart had kits with such a cruel she cat,She changed Stormkit's name to Crockedkit!C'mon Rainflower,you didn't need to do that,you just made Stormkit feel worse

Sandstorm

[Deleted]

Sandstorm was a well developed character, I liked her. Her change from being the all cruel monster into Firestar's mate was cute t

Mapleshade

[Speckledpaw]

Mapleshade didn't deserve to go to the Dark Forest.After all,she just wanted a mate who loved and respected her,Mapleshade probably chose one from other clan because there was no cat who actually was nice to her in her own clan.And Mapleshade turned into a bad cat because her mate left and blamed her for everything:Especially about the kits that drowned.
If Appledusk didn't want the kits to drown he should have crossed the river with the kits himself
She wasn't that bad

Crowfeather

[Talia]

Now for me, Crowfeather is a mix. I like him but don't at the same time. I think it was cute for him to make his name Crowteather for Feathertail (I think that was her name...) My favorite was the leafpool and Crowfeather ship, but him and Nightcloud was a bit sad. Because she loved him but he didn't I think she should have not lied about loving her.
Yellowfang

[Emberpaw]

He was quick and bad-temperd the first time he was introduced into the books, though I've got a soft, but stern spot for him. He was just a cat; he didn't deserve to have his first two mates taken away from him. Though he's got to be proud of his three kits with Leafapool, or at least two of them. (sorry. Tailia posted when I was about to post)

I've got somewhat of a sarcastic pace for her, though it's full of humor. So she did something, no everything wrong, doesen't mean she's a bad cat. Her sarcastic place fits her sarcastic actions, but still, retort, after retort, she died honorably, and retorts, are commently ment for jokes in my opinion.

Spottedleaf (My favorite cat in the books, along with Dovewing.)

[Deleted]

I loved Yellowfang a lot, she was a grumpy cat on the outside by on the inside she was all fluff. I think she was one of the best characters in the books for bringing in an awesome villain, blinding him, killing him, and killing him again =D

Stonefur

[Sunfish]

Loved him. The way he died was sad and unfair. He was a good warrior.

Blackstar

[Deleted]

I really, really, don't like Blackstar. Sure, he became better but... I just found him insufferable because he killed my favorite character (Stonefur) And I just can't get over it.

Russetfur

[Emberpaw]

Urg... listen to me this time....

RUSSETFUR: She was okay. I mean, it's not on my mind now, and I'm where Russetfur is seeming a little 'old' now, but, humph. Don't pay attention to her lurking in the background.

Thunderstar (Thunder)

[Deleted]

He had a sad, abusive by father backstory.

Shadowstar {We'll go full circle X3}