What If? *spoilers*

[Deleted]

Oakheart wouldn't have died and Mistystar would lead ThunderClan instead. And Mosskit would be alive and become a strong warrior.


Could make it longer but... kinda busy....


What If; Scourge was good? :3

[Deleted]

Tigers tar would take over the clan.




What if the cats had gelato

(Gelato is Italian ice cream but better)

[Dawnbreeze]

Um, well the cats wouldnt eat it cause there sweet toothe xD

What if Brightheart never got attacked by that dog!

[Aspenfang]

Swiftpaw would’ve had gone alone to face the dog pack, and would still ended up dead. Brightpaw, on the other hand, would’ve remained in camp and never gotten her injured. But because of this she would have most likely received a different warrior name (most likely sharing her naming ceremony with her brother, Thornpaw). She also would know a lot less about herbs, and most likely would’ve not been chosen to mentor Jaypaw.

What if Flametail was the third cat, instead of Dovewing?

[Dawnbreeze]

(I would be HAPPY i hate Dovewing) Dovewing would never had become special. Ivypool would never been jealous and gone to the dark forest so theyed have no spy and the batttle would have happened and everyone was unprepared so they died and Tigerclaw would rule!


What if Tigerclaw fell in love with IVYPOOL

[Moonshine]

He would have tried to convince her to join him during the fight with all of the Clans, and she would have ultimately rejected him due to here loyalty to ThunderClan. This would cause him to become so enraged that he would kill her in and then killed her again once she was a StarClan cat.

What if Brambleclaw let Hawkfrost kill Firestar?

[Dawnbreeze]

Firestar would die there would be no big battle cause Firestars dead but squirrel flight would lose brabmleclaw!

[Deleted]

(Psst, Dawnbreeze you frogot to put a thing)
Oh well, I would just say: What if Ivypool's jealousy made her stay int he Dark Forest

    Well first, she would never tell when the attack was happening to Jayfeather, Lionblaze and Dovewing. Then she would become an ever greater warrior because she LIKED to spill blood. Ivypool would convince Blossomfall, Birchfall, Thornclaw, and Mousewhisker to fight alongside her Dark Forest Clanmates. The Dark Forest would fail though, and she would get killed by Bumblestripe because she tried to kill Dovewing. And then she would be trapped in the Dark Forest Forever.

I actually like that better than what they decided to do with her in the books, oh well.

What if Jessy the Kittypet stayed in Thunderclan? (From Bramblestar's Storm)

[Moonshine]

She and Brambleclaw would become mates and eventual have kits. Although this would completely break the relationship between him and Squirrelflight. With the deputy and leader not talking or barely speaking to one another, ThunderClan would slowly begin to crumble.

What if Feathertail never died?

[Aspenfang]

If Feathertail never died then: ((and this is assuming she still killed Sharptooth))
1) She would have become mates with Crowfeather, and he would have never fallen in love with Leafpool
2) Because Crowfeather did not fall in love with Leafpool, Jayfeather and Lionblaze would have never been born so the prophesy could have never been fulfilled /by them/
3) Breezepelt would have never existed, since Crowfeather would have never had kits with Nightcloud to make Leafpool jealous
4) Hollyleaf would have never been born, and Ashfur would still be alive
5) Squirrelflight would have never had to lie to Brambleclaw about being the mother of Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf, so they would still be on good terms. They would also most likely have had their own kits sooner, since Yellowfang would have never needed to tell Squirrelflight that she could never have kits.
6) Crowfeather would have most likely received a different warrior name, since he got named the suffix “feather” for his lost Feathertail 6)
7) Stormfur might have decided to stay with the Clans; which would also most likely result in the Tribe of Rushing Water being killed/taken over by the band of rouges
8) She wouldn’t be able to give Mistystar a life

I think thats all. So, What if Bluestar and Oakheart never met.

[Dawnbreeze]

Things would be much easier they would never had kits Mosskit never would have died! But bluestar might have never beileived firestar
(In my opinion if jessie stayed in thunderclan i would cry i hated her i loved squirrelflight)

What if squirrelflight fell in love with featherstorms brother (I forgot his name XC)

[Deleted]

She would have joined the tribe


What if the two legs never invaded the old forest

[Dawnbreeze]

They would stay in the forest. Jayfeather would have never met rock . Hollyleaf would have never left . Ashfur would be alive. Rock wouldnt have ever talked to jayfeather. There would be no tribe of rushing waters!

[Deleted]

(DANG IT DAWN, YOU FORGOT AGAIN)

    I'll put this: What if Squirrelflight chose Ashfur?

1] Brambleclaw would have killed Firestar in the fox trap as punishment for leaving him
2] Brambleclaw would get kicked out for killing the leader, and then they chose Ashfur to be leader, and he picked Brakenfur or something to be deputy
3] They would have kits before Leafpool's kits were born, so Leafpool gave her kits to Crowfeather in secret so she didn't quit being a medicine cat
4] Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze would grow up in Windclan, and Lionblaze would have kits with Heathertail.
5] Sunspots would finally eat ice cream.

Squirrelflight X Ashfur 4ever <3

What if Lionblaze kept meeting Heathertail?

[Deleted]

They would remain friends and then become mates, but Hollyleaf would hate her brother for breaking the warrior code. She would tell Firestar, and Lionblaze would be watched to make sure they stopped meeting. But they still talked in secret here and there, and soon, Heathertail was bearing his kits. Breezepelt was furious, and he tried to kill Lionblaze-only to fail because of Lionblaze's powers. Then Lionblaze joined WindClan to be with Heathertail, making most of the cats his enemies.

The kits were raised in WindClan. Lionblaze still tried to help the prophecy, but he was more set on his duty to WindClan. Cinderheart never had a reason not to become the medicine cat, and so Cinderpelt's spirit wasn't satisfied. But Ashfur spilled the beans at the Gathering, and everyone hated the kits. And then boom bang, poor cats we're killed and Ashfur succeeded in defending himself from Hollyleaf and actually killed her(noooooo) and the prophecy was messed up and Jay and Lion were depressed.

And they lost the battle to the Dark Forest because Hollyleaf couldn't save Ivypool, and Lionblaze didn't leave Heathertail's side, and Jayfeather would feel alone because his siblings left him so he decided to ignore Rock and stay with Half Moon, ultimately leading to his death in his sleep yet his mind remained with his love. And also Jay Wing was alive to see the first Clan cats leave, and even went with them, despite being an elder, and became the first medicine cat of ThunderClan which led to many different fates and settings.

This didn't turn really dark, mostly strange... I fully support Lionblaze and Heathertail, though! And Jay and Half Moon!


What If: Ivypool was the actually "third" cat, and Hollyleaf was the "fourth"?